This post is in response to Mitch's post last week. You can read that here.
Mitch you are a smart guy and obviously a very passionate one. Your passion got in the way of your argument on how the ACC needs Florida State so badly. In your rant, you seemed to be grasping at straws, trying to hold onto this season and the hope that the Fisher era was supposed to bring. This season, Florida State is sitting at 4-3 to the surprise of everyone, we all expected much more from this team. It's hard to feel you have a better team than your record shows. We can blame the media for telling us that FSU was supposed to be the team to beat in the ACC but it seemed valid at the time. Florida State seemed to be the ACC team with the fewest question marks at the beginning of the season. But this is not about this season, this is about Florida State's decade and how the ACC doesn't need its dominance anymore.
I will not sit here and deny what Florida State did to/for the ACC the first few years they were in the conference. Florida State's domination forced the hands of John Swofford to bring in teams that might defeat them. Because of FSU's dominance, Virginia Tech now gets to play in the ACC and doesn't have to worry about the dying Big East.
What I will deny is that the ACC needs Florida State to dominate this conference now. You call it the "lost decade" but the only "lost" seasons I see are 2006 and 2007, where the NCAA made Florida State forfeit wins because of the cheating scandal. I do appreciate your willingness to admit the cheating scandal but don't try to blame the administration. Student athletes cheated and it was wide spread. That makes it much more than an administration issue.
I assume this "lost decade" begins in 2001 when Florida State didn't win the ACC title. That year Maryland won the ACC in Ralph Friedgen's first season as Maryland's head coach. That Maryland team finished 10-2 on the season. (Remember that Ralph Friendgen finished with 10-wins in his first season, it will come up later.)
In 2002 and 2003, Florida State would win two more ACC Championships, before Virginia Tech, Miami and Boston College would enter the ACC. Virginia Tech would win the conference in 2004, then Florida State would win the first ACC Championship game in 2005 but since then Florida State has not won the conference and only played in the Championship game one time.
Florida State has continued to win enough games to be bowl eligible the last few seasons and kept a very impressive streak of bowl game appearances going. The streak is now up to 29 straight bowl appearances. (I won't mention how FSU should have not played in two of those because of the teams use of ineligible players because that's too easy.)
What Florida State has not done is be an important part of this conference. The biggest news coming out of Tallahassee this past "decade" was the will they-won't they with the firing of Bobby Bowden. It was more reality show than football program and as the program continued it's slide, the games weren't the focus but instead all the off the field issues.
While Florida State was deciding on "how to solve a problem like Bobby" the Atlantic Division was won by Boston College twice and Clemson and Wake Forest both once. Two of these teams you decided to mock in your rant and the other probably doesn't even deserve your mocking but I bring them up to say, this is who picked up the slack for your "lost decade". I'll also point out that the only one of these teams to win the Conference Championship was Wake Forest in a 9-6 "slugfest" in 2006.
That's all to say this, the ACC gift wrapped a Championship game each season by placing Florida State with great football programs like Wake Forest, NC State and Maryland. Virginia Tech, Georgia Tech and Miami would have loved playing those teams year in and year out.
So you have had a "lost decade" we will both admit that. I wanted to make sure we spelled it out and let the readers see what has happened in Tallahassee in better detail. In May of 2010, months before you would play in the ACC Championship game for the first time since 2005, the ACC would renew a television contract with ESPN. It is not the biggest contract for any conference I will admit but the contract is worth $1.86 billion over 12 years. The few seasons before this contract was signed, Florida State was not even ACC relevant. Did ESPN give ACC a new contract based on Florida State's potential? I doubt it. ESPN signed a contract with the ACC despite Florida State's lack of success.
Florida State fans I didn't write this to rip into Florida State. I write this in quite the opposite. I wanted Florida State to be good this year. I ultimately wanted Virginia Tech to beat them in the ACC Championship game but I was hoping Florida State would win against Oklahoma and finish the season relatively unscathed. The ACC needs a second team. Virginia Tech has been the face of this conference the past few seasons. I know I write that as a Virginia Tech fan but there is no way around it. Conferences need more than one team to bring the conference any type of respect. The ACC originally hoped it would be Florida State and Miami but neither team did their part. I don't care who it is at this point.
Mitch, I don't blame you for getting excited about Florida State's return to national prominence. FSU got rid of Bobby Bowden, they brought in a #1 recruiting class, the new coach took the team to the ACC Championship last season and that team had a 10-win season. But you need to also remember that you had to rely on Maryland beating NC State the last weekend of the regular season so that you could play in the ACC Championship. Remember that you showed nothing against Virginia Tech in that Championship game. You are very excited about Jimbo Fisher starting his career with 10-wins. Now remember that Ralph Friedgen did that in his first year at Maryland. Obviously there are very few coaches to reach that mark in their first season but knowing Friedgen was able to did it should help curb the enthusiasm. Florida State's future dominance of the conference is not preordained and shouldn't be assumed, no matter how much you want to believe the hype.
I appreciate recognizing that this is not about one year but several. The big picture is lost on most. I also appreciate that you see the ACC needs FSU to win again, "The ACC needs a second team".
ReplyDeleteI don't disagree that VT has been the team in the ACC since joining. But how has that worked out for the conference? Let's look to the height of conference success and who achieved it.
I'm not pro ACC because I think they cater to their original universities, but by way of me wanting the FSU to be great mean I want the ACC to be great because we're the ones who will get them there.
Always remember, chees not checkers. It will allow you to survey the conference, the programs, and the trends and realize the hype is the commencement of the FSU reign but not yet the consumation.
If you look back at the paragraph where you got the "The ACC needs a second team" quote I also said "I don't care who it is at this point." FSU does not have to be that second team. Maybe this season is when Clemson turns the corner and has year in, year out success. This season could be an aberration we don't know. Just like last year might have been for FSU.
ReplyDeleteI cannot agree with you that the ACC as a whole caters to their original universities. Maybe I am just missing it but I think the conference has treated Virginia Tech well. I will admit I think the ACC media is biased to the original universities but that is something completely different. ACC media is just like everything else in the South, an old gentlemen's club but give it time and that will change. I can only speak for Virginia Tech but I think the conference has been great for/to us. Good enough that Virginia Tech denied any interest in the SEC when our name was thrown around in SEC expansion talk a few months ago.
Last thing I don't need to hear anymore about FSU being back. Everyone knows where Tallahassee is, we will see it when you are back.